Another installment of jibs vs drones! This time, let chat about the practicality of both. Say you want to do live sweeping shots a parade and be connected to a live switch. That seems like it’s a slam dunk for a jib right right? However, it’s surprising the number of people that are trying to turn to drones for this. Of course, the drone can soar far about the parade lending views a jib could never do! But is this practical? First of all, let’s forget the legality issues with doing that as it’s sort of obvious there would be loads of them. Let’s focus on work flows. A drone needs frequent battery changes, is not as weather proof, and only get you a handful of shots. Jibs can run off AC and don’t burn thru battery power nearly as fast, so that lets us provide much more sustained coverage. With proper rain gear, jib rigs are impervious to torrential rain that would make a drone crash almost instantly. The drone would be locked into some kind of blimp camera angle. That’s an amazing shot, but it’s not nearly as versatile as a jib would be. When I’m jibbing a parade for example, I position the end of my arm to come within a few feet of the floats. This lets me very high and wide but still maintain an eye angle to the people on the ground. It also lets me zoom right into close ups of people on the float and give the effect of flight within that space. Doing this with a drone would certainly be an amazing skill set, but those propellors can slice a person up very easily so it’s just too risky. Even the smallest contact with a tiny branch can knock an sUAS out of the sky. For now and years to come, it’s simply not technologically feasible to do this kind of camera work with a drone. This doesn’t mean a drone shouldn’t be considered for some grandiose high and wide shots, they will look amazing!
Jib Vs Drones Part 2: Legal
The saga continues, Drone or Jib?? They both have their uses but this series is more about considerations which may not always be obvious and that leads up to the legal subject. Not all drone operations are legal to do in the eyes of the FAA. Furthermore, the rules of Part 107 gave communities the go ahead to make their own laws and ordinances on the subject. Flying within the rules of the FAA may actually be violating some kind of local regulation. For example, there are plenty areas within New York City that are not Class B controlled airspace but the city still has banned drones everywhere except AMA fields. Other towns in NJ have made it illegal to fly a drone anywhere other than the lateral limits of private property. It’s getting intense nonetheless! Jibs are still a very handy resource in red tape situations like these.
What is helpful is that an automatic authorization system for surface level class B, C, D, and E airspace has gone live around many airports in the country. This changed the authorization process massively as it may only take a few moments on an app vs 90 days with the FAA. However, what do you do if you can’t get an authorization OR you get an authorization but local regulations prevent you from flying?? If you can’t get authorized, it’s game over. Then it’s jib time. If you do get authorized but it’s still illegal to fly? You may be dealing with red tape, more asking for permission, or going back to the ole reliable camera jib.
Drone flights directly over people are still NOT allowed by the FAA or by local governments. You can fly “around” people but the flight path can’t go directly over anyone. Some cities have restricted this even further by creating specific regulations to keep drones away from people. For massive shots directly over people, jibs still are the best and safest option.
If you think airspace may cause an entanglement for a shoot you a planning, please feel free to reach out to me at steve@Universaljibs.com to discuss options!
Jib and Drone Footage: Fun with Slow Mo!
In my spare time I’ll get out into more secluded areas in NJ and break out the drone. Slow mo helps capture the true beauty of natural elements. They often happen way too fast to take them in so seeing them from angles you can’t be in or at speeds that don’t exist is a great way to change things up. Check it out. I promise this waterafall is much bigger in real life. It’s approximately 25’ from the base to the top!